August 1, 2013
The state will shut down its overdue and over-budget computer system update it intended to modernize its unemployment claims and processing.
Pennsylvania Department of Labor & Industry Secretary Julia Hearthway said the $153 million — so far — upgrade to the Unemployment Compensation Modernization System, which was in its third and final phase, will be terminated immediately without spending additional public money.
The third phase of the upgrade deals with taking online unemployment claims and paying benefits.
“It’s simply not working,” Hearthway said at a news conference Wednesday morning in Harrisburg. “The system we had hoped for from IBM simply isn’t there.”
The state will continue to use its current system, which was never turned off during the upgrade process. The system is old, Hearthway said, but is reliable.
“It’s like your old Chevy,” she said. “It’s an old clunker … but it gets you from Point A to Point B.”
She said the state is now investigating how much money may have to be invested in the old system to keep it running before the system upgrade can be continued. There is no timeline for when a new vendor can come in to continue the work on the system, she said.
The system upgrade has been an albatross for the department for a decade. Conceived in 2003, the state awarded the contract for the upgrade to IBM in 2006 with the intention of having it up and ready by January 2010.
“But it was plagued with problems and delays” from the outset, Hearthway said.
The first two phases of the upgrade of the system have been completed and will be instituted, but the third phase — which took up the largest chunk of the work and the funding — will be scrapped.
Hearthway said she couldn’t put an exact dollar figure on how much money was spent on the failed phase three, only that it was a “majority” of the $153 million — more than $75 million.
She said the matter has been handed over to the Pennsylvania Office of General Counsel to determine whether legal action should be taken against IBM to recoup some of that money.
State Rep. William Keller, the Democratic chairman of the Labor and Industry Committee, said the upgrade started with the best intentions, but spiraled out of control.
The abandonment of the system comes after a yearlong study by the Software Engineering Institute at Carnegie Mellon University to determine what the state should do about the UCSM project.
The study, which the state paid $100,000 for, Hearthway said, recommended stopping the process. The institute will continue on as a consultant in the process, she said.
Visually Impaired Preschool Services has been a client of First Non-Profit since it was first offered as a benefit of VisionServe Alliance. We completed a thorough evaluation of cash savings to our agency before taking advantage of this wonderful benefit and it has been a very wise decision. Our experience with the processes from accounting to claims have been professional, expeditious and easy.
The Ensight Skills Center has enjoyed working with First Nonprofit for several years. We are enrolled in their Unemployment Savings Program and although we have not required a lot of intervention, there have been a few times. I know others have dealt with the same problem of unemployment fraud over the last year and in our case, a call to First Nonprofit (they actually answer their phones) cleared up the issue. They also sent us a letter to send to all our employees telling them what they needed to do to prevent this in the future and protect themselves. What a relief! Over the years if I have questions or concerns, they are happy to listen, advise and help if they can. Another BIG advantage of using First Nonprofit is that all the money that is paid into the Unemployment Savings Program lives on my balance sheet as an asset. The money continues to be Ensight’s not the governments. First Nonprofit has certainly given me peace of mind.
In addition to their money-saving purpose on behalf of nonprofit organizations like AHS, First Nonprofit’s Nonprofit Unemployment Fund streamlines the information we need to efficiently manage unemployment claims. Our relationship with NU Fund gave us access to such things as advice on planning for what’s ahead and how to analyze cost scenarios when unexpected events occurred. Both experiences were very helpful.
We have had a great experience with FNP. During Covid, when there was the chance that reimbursable nonprofits would have to pay 50% of the unemployment costs, FNP went to bat for us. We would receive weekly information on the Unemployment claim and how they were working to reduce the costs to reimbursable nonprofits. They have a great service also working with [our claims administrator] to make sure all the paperwork is completed correctly for any unemployment claim.
PORT Health Services has had a great experience with the Unemployment Savings Program offered through First Nonprofit. Throughout the years we have been involved in the program, we have increased our reserve account significantly through this program and find the reporting we receive both timely and useful. We look forward to our continued involvement with this program and our connection with First Nonprofit for many years to come.
Job One was spending a lot of money on unemployment. Our insurance broker, Mark Simcosky, recommended that we switch over to First Nonprofit. We did just that! This switch has been a huge savings for us! This switch saved us over $10,000 in the first year. Their customer service is Superior! Any time we have a question, we get a response very quickly. Any time we send them a report and they have a question; they call rather than just assuming. They were very responsive during COVID, even when they were in crisis mode their selves. They also were always there when we needed during COVID and very helpful! We would 1,000% recommend First Nonprofit to anybody that could benefit from it!
My experience with FNP has always been positive. Every time I have had to contact them, I’m always put in contact with a friendly and knowledgeable person. If something is missing from our account, they reach out to us to request it. It’s nice to work with a company that makes sure our account is current. I would recommend them to any nonprofit looking to reduce their unemployment insurance costs.
We’ve saved tens of thousands of dollars PER YEAR by changing to become a reimbursing employer, freeing funds for much needed capital investment. FNP has been a valued partner in this process, providing assurance that we have stopgap coverage for extraordinary claims and keeping claims response painless and simple. It’s a huge Win/Win!